There isn't only war, actually. Sorry about that. It's just that ever since Krugman started a blood feud covered by every minor news organization out there, I'm in a feud state of mind.
Anyway, a week or so ago, Ruhlman put up a post called "My Essential Kitchen Tools" on his blog, and I thought I'd just run down his list and see how I compare with world-famous food author, television personality, and Bourdain confidante Michael J. Ruhlman.
KNIVES:
Ruhlman says you need one good big knife and one good small knife. Coincidentally, I own one good big knife and one good small knife. We concur, except that Cathy got me our first proper bread knife for my birthday, and I have no idea what the fuck I was thinking struggling with that shitty bread knife I bought fifteen years ago as part of a $20 set when a tiny outlay of money could utterly transform my bread-slicing experience. So one good big knife, one good small knife, and one good bread knife.
CUTTING BOARD:
Ruhlman demands a Boos. It costs a hundred dollars. It looks like a big thick wooden cutting board. I have a big thick wooden cutting board, too. It didn't cost me 96 dollars. Now, mine may not be maple, and it has no hand grips, and it's not two feet wide because that would put the edge of it into my fromt left burner, but I think I paid twenty bucks for it, because it's a big piece of wood.
PANS:
What Ruhlman says - one each large and small saute pan, and one each large and small saucepan, which I still call small pots. Also one large pot. This is just in the basic silvery metal category. I have like four large pots at this point, in sizes ranging from casual to gifuckingnormous. I don't use my stainless steel saute pans anymore, um, ever, now that I think about it. I use my cast-iron pans or my non-stick or my wok.
DUTCH OVEN:
Here Ruhlman has it all over me, because he loves enameled cast-iron dutch ovens, and I love enameled cast-iron dutch ovens, and he sells books and goes on the teevee, and I buy video games. So he has at least one enameled cast-iron dutch oven, and I have yet to give La Crueset a single penny of my money.
NON-STICK PANS:
Ruhlman says buy an expensive one and treat it nice. Alton Brown says buy cheap ones and replace them when they start to disintegrate. I like Ruhlman a lot, but I trust Brown more, plus it helps me be cheap. One large, one small cheap non-stick, but the small one was apparently too cheap, as the edges are starting to peel after only a few months of limited use.
STANDING MIXER AND FOOD PROCESSOR:
Fuck yes. In fact, I think Ruhlman and I have the same food processor - I just bought mine in white and as a refurb so it cost like half as much.
MANDOLINE:
I don't have one right now, because I thought I wanted the Oxo Good Grips one, got it as a gift, and fucking haaaaaaaated it. Hate. Ed. It. So it went to Goodwill and I haven't gotten around to replacing it. This is the one instance where Ruhlman recommends something cheaper than what I'd been using, so maybe I'll take his advice on a 2- bicl Benrinner.
STICK BLENDER:
He has a stick blender someone gave him. I have a stick blender someone gave me. Mine has a metal shaft.
DIGITAL PROBE THERMOMETER:
Check, though not in the array. I have one remote-probe thermometer that goes up just high enough for fry oil, though my one attempt at using it that way failed miserably. Someday, I want a Thermapen and an infrared thermometer, but I don't need those for cooking, I need them because I'm a NERRRRRRD.
MICROPLANE:
Absofuckinglutely. Zest, grated ginger, grated garlic, grated nutmeg. I have a slightly larger grater I use for hard cheese.
He mentions a scale briefly. I've bought two kitchen scales since I started this site - one because I wanted to measure stuff for Forkbastard, and one because I fucking dumped the fucking first one on the fucking floor and fucking broke it. Huzzah for the monthly Bed Bath and Beyond coupon, is all I have to say.
Things I couldn't live without that Ruhlman fails to mention - my big-ass cast-iron wok. My big-ass cast-iron double-burner combo griddle and grill pan. More prep bowls than I can comfortably store. Garlic press that looks like a tiny ricer. And a bladed egg/mushroom slicer that I never, ever slice eggs with, because hard-boiled eggs are disgusting.
Comments
Cast Iron Dutch Oven
Sun, 04/18/2010 - 18:53 — Blotz (not verified)Target has a cast iron dutch oven that's not quite as nice as the french fuckers but will definitely do the job for about $50.
I'll add that I never thought I'd need a tomato knife until I bought one and now I use it all summer.
I'll ditto your take on the OXO V-slicer. Mine was a gift and I only bust it out every so often, so I can live with it.
I picked up a lodge cast iron
Sun, 04/25/2010 - 16:18 — Dar (not verified)I picked up a lodge cast iron 6 qt dutch oven for $50 and then picked up the fancy stainless steel replacement knob/handle for the top that Le Creuset makes for another $10 off of Amazon. I haven't been dissapointed at all, especially not when I look at the equivalent LC model for around $250.
items not mentioned
Mon, 04/19/2010 - 09:18 — Eric (not verified)#1 on my list that was not covered are my sheet pans. I have a bunch of the old fashioned cookie sheets that we all grew up with, and never touch them, because the half and quarter sheet pans are so completely better. They're solid - they never warp. They're sturdy - you can put anything on them, and not be afraid that they're going to fold.
Also, do you not yet have an Alton standard Polder probe thermometer? I thought that, and a salt cellar were the basics for being an Alton fan. Absolutely vital, to me especially, in not overcooking chicken and pork.
Also, also, get that dutch oven. You need it. It took us way too long to get ours, but we adore it.
Salt, Sheet, Probe
Mon, 04/19/2010 - 10:23 — Bryan LambertI have a remote probe thermometer, just not a handheld one. I don't even think of a salt cellar as a tool - I have one, but it's just an open-topped jar to keep salt in. I don't have a fancy flip-top one.
I, too, use basic aluminum sheet pans for... everything, and love them for the exact same reasons. I got two large and two small ones at a restaurant supply store many years ago, and they're still in great shape to this day.
Half-sheet pans, Shirley.
Tue, 04/20/2010 - 12:18 — vortechHalf-sheet pans, Shirley. Sheet pans won't fit in many home ovens.
You can further justify yourself by noting the America's test kitchen bothe recommend the cheaper non-stich theory and note that the non-stick erodes no matter how nice you treat it.
I convinced some fool to get me a thermapen/IR package for birthmas and I can now say with confidence, you need the IR thing because you are a neeerd. The actual thermapen is absurdly better than any probe thermometer I have had previously.
Lodge makes my enameled cast iron and it seems every bit as good and pretty as a le cruset at like 60% of the price. Cook's illus. recommends cheapos get some thing they found at wall-mart from a company called tremolina, but I hate going to wall mart and it looked like crap and you had to remove the lid's handle because it was not oven safe. Pass.
I guess I'm more into baking than he, but I can't imagine having a kitchen without a board scraper. Ditto prep bowls — what an odd omission. Also, a digital scale and measuring spoons.
Yeah, halves and quarters are what I got, I assume
Tue, 04/20/2010 - 13:10 — Bryan Lambert...and don't call me Shirley.
The thermapen
Wed, 04/21/2010 - 10:40 — Blotz (not verified)I loved my thermapen, and I just bought a probe setup from that company, but that $90 thermometer makes for an attrctive paperweight if'n you get it wet, like say at your 4th of july BBQ. (it has rained on 4th of july in Cincinnati for 3 straight years).
the new thermapen (mine) is
Wed, 04/28/2010 - 19:05 — vortechthe new thermapen (mine) is splashproof.